What's wrong with American Idol

is that it does not have singers like these. From the British TV show that "Idol" is a Bizarro copy of, Paul Potts:



and Susan Boyle:



"Ted Mack's Amateur Hour" and "Arthur Godfrey's Talent Scouts" had more diversity than American Idol.

(Those related videos from the Susan Boyle clip will open as pop-ups and may be blocked by a pop-up blocker.)